Introducing The Keeping Room (2014) – A Haunting Tale of Feminism and War

The Keeping Room (2014) is a gripping drama with elements of a Western and thriller, directed by Daniel Barber and written by Julia Hart. Set during the final days of the American Civil War in 1865, the film offers a unique perspective, focusing on the experiences of three women in the South as they confront the brutality of war. Featuring a talented cast including Brit Marling, Hailee Steinfeld, Muna Otaru, and Sam Worthington, the movie is not only a story of survival but also a profound commentary on feminism, race, and the devastating impact of war.

Basic Information

• Director: Daniel Barber
• Writer: Julia Hart
• Cast: Brit Marling (Augusta), Hailee Steinfeld (Louise), Muna Otaru (Mad), Sam Worthington (Moses), Kyle Soller (Henry)
• Genres: Drama, Western, Thriller
• Runtime: 95 minutes
• Rating: R (contains violence and sensitive themes)
• Release Date: September 25, 2015 (limited release in the U.S.), May 4, 2016 (Netflix U.S.)
• Production Companies: Wind Dancer Films, Gilbert Films, Anonymous Content
• Distributor: Drafthouse Films

Plot Summary

Set in 1865, as the American Civil War nears its end, The Keeping Room follows two sisters, Augusta (Brit Marling) and Louise (Hailee Steinfeld), and Mad (Muna Otaru), an enslaved woman who once worked for their family. Living in isolation on a Southern farm, the three women are left to fend for themselves after the men in their family have gone to war and never returned.

The story begins when Augusta ventures out to find medicine for Louise, who is injured after a raccoon bite. During her trip, she catches the attention of two deserters from the Union Army, Moses (Sam Worthington) and Henry (Kyle Soller). Drunk and dehumanized by years of war, the two soldiers pursue Augusta after she escapes an attack. When they track her to the farm, Augusta, Louise, and Mad must take up arms to defend their home and lives against increasingly violent and unpredictable assaults. The film evolves from a tale of survival into a tense psychological and physical battle, showcasing the women’s resilience and unity in the face of danger.

Highlights of the Film

1. A Unique Feminist Perspective

Unlike most Civil War films that focus on male experiences, The Keeping Room centers on women caught in the chaos of war. Augusta, Louise, and Mad face not only physical threats but also societal prejudices about gender and race. The film skillfully portrays the evolution of their relationships, from master and servant to a sisterly bond, delivering a powerful message about female solidarity and strength in adversity.

2. Tense and Haunting Atmosphere

Blending the aesthetics of a Western with the intensity of a “home invasion” thriller, The Keeping Room creates a chilling atmosphere with a slow yet gripping pace. Director Daniel Barber uses long silences and minimalist visuals to evoke unease, keeping viewers on edge. The film’s violent scenes are raw and unflinching, highlighting the cruelty of war and its toll on humanity.

3. Stellar Performances

The cast is a standout feature of the film. Brit Marling delivers a powerful performance as Augusta, a strong yet vulnerable leader of the group. Hailee Steinfeld, as Louise, portrays a young girl’s transformation into a resilient woman. Muna Otaru’s portrayal of Mad is deeply moving, particularly in scenes that explore the complexities of her life as an enslaved woman. Sam Worthington and Kyle Soller provide chilling performances as the brutal soldiers, serving as stark contrasts to the three women.

4. Cinematography and Music

Filmed in Romania, the movie captures the desolate beauty of a war-torn South with stark, haunting landscapes. Cinematographer Martin Ruhe uses muted, cold tones and wide shots to emphasize the characters’ isolation and vulnerability. The minimalist score enhances the film’s tension and sense of foreboding.

Reception and Reviews

The Keeping Room received mixed reviews from critics. On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds a 75% approval rating based on 83 reviews, with critics noting that it is “bolstered by its lean setting and committed performances, distinctive enough to overcome its flaws.” On Metacritic, it scored 58/100 based on 21 reviews, indicating “mixed or average” feedback. Critics praised the film’s feminist themes and bold storytelling, though some felt the slow pacing and occasional heavy-handed dialogue detracted from its impact.

Audiences appreciated the strong performances, particularly from the female leads, and the film’s unflinching portrayal of violence and trauma. However, some viewers found the pacing sluggish and the plot lacking depth, which may affect the viewing experience for those expecting a faster-paced narrative.

Why You Should Watch The Keeping Room

• If you enjoy Westerns or thrillers with a fresh perspective, this film offers a rare focus on women’s experiences in a historical setting often overlooked.
• It’s ideal for viewers interested in social themes like feminism, race, and the consequences of war explored through an artistic lens.
• The powerful performances and striking visuals make it a compelling watch, even if the pacing may not suit fans of action-packed films.

Viewer Advisory

The film is rated R for its graphic violence, including scenes of sexual violence, and the use of sensitive language (e.g., racial slurs and profanity). These elements may be disturbing for some viewers, particularly those sensitive to themes of war and gender-based violence. The movie is best suited for mature audiences who appreciate thought-provoking dramas.

Conclusion

The Keeping Room is not an easy watch, but it’s a rewarding one thanks to its powerful message and unique storytelling. Despite some flaws in pacing and plot development, the film leaves a lasting impression with its stellar performances and fresh perspective on the American Civil War. If you’re looking for a tense, thought-provoking drama, The Keeping Room is worth your time.

Where to Watch?

• Netflix (availability varies by region, check your platform).
• Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, or other rental platforms.
• Blu-ray/DVD from Drafthouse Films.

Share your thoughts after watching and let us know if this emotional story resonates with you!